Skip to content

Food, Industrialization, Urbanization

Stumbled across an interested series of posts (first one here) on the history of English food written by Rachel Laudan. Laudan is writing in response to an old blogpost by Paul Krugman, written in 1998, that used English food’s putative crappiness to demonstrate the bad equilibrium thesis. Essentially, the thinking is that a free market can get caught in a “bad equilibrium” where only bad goods are supplied because decent ones have never been available, and hence generate no demand. This applies to English food, Krugman assumes, because England’s early industrialization and urbanization caused the English to be exposed only to the poor-quality, mass-produced foods that industry can muster to satiate an urban populace. Hence, because the English had never tasted good food, they never demanded good food, and in the absence of a compelling demand, suppliers produced only bad food, and so the English only bought bad food. Vicious circle.

You get this sort of gnostic thinking in economics pretty often; to Krugman’s credit, the original post was for a fluff piece on a blog, and bloggers do have to wax intelligent often and in so many words. But Laudan proceeds to dismantle the notion that industry or cities mean bad food, thankfully without delving into any of the assumptions that make the bad-equilibrium thesis appear compelling. Instead, she dives into the fine-grained details of food history, exploring the notion that cities are conducive to poor food (They’re not, and if you think about it for a moment, that should be obvious: where do you find the finest cuisines? In the provinces or in the capital?), and then investigating how industrialized food-production unfolded, historically (food was a latecomer to the industrialization party). She does not mention abstract demands meeting abstract supplies in an abstract market and coming to equilibrium; instead, she presents historical evidence that shows that urbanization and industrialization need not bring about mushy peas and and sad meat pies. An upcoming post will present Laudan’s own thoughts about what was at play in the historical development of English cuisine.

(It should be noted that none of Laudan’s points actually contradict the bad equilibrium thesis. But the whole example of English food itself begs the question: who’s to say that English food is bad? Of course, the thesis doesn’t really explain much, anyway. There will always be more proximate causes for the operations of a market than an abstraction about supply, demand, and utility.)

The exercise in food history is interesting in and of itself, of course — I found the statistics on caloric intake and bread and the amount of money a family spent on bread to be highly informative: brings new resonance to slogans like Peace, Land, Bread — but more interesting is what it says or suggests about how various forms of industry have coexisted, and might in the future. At least from the perspective of anyone interested in maintaining the productive capacities of industrialization while not foisting pink slime onto the food supply.

Categories: Notes.

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

Comment Feed

29 Responses

  1. A user can click on on ‘start a hang out’
    that makes him visible to any or all the folks as part of his social
    circles and send them a notification that their friend is going out
    and they are able to join the hang out and begin a youtube video chat inside a private chat room.

    For beginners, it is strongly suggested to come up with a strategy just
    before using Google Ad - Words as this method involves monetary investment.

    Exact match - using this type, you’ll want to apply the square brackets [ ] throughout the search
    phrase which narrows the search even further.

  2. I am not positive where you’re getting your information, but great topic.
    I must spend a while learning more or working out more.
    Thanks for excellent information I was searching
    for this information for my mission.

  3. Greate pieces. Keep posting such kind of information on your page.

    Im really impressed by your site.
    Hi there, You’ve done an excellent job. I will certainly digg it and in my view suggest to my friends.

    I am sure they will be benefited from this site.

  4. In doing so, you will be able to make sure you are obtaining the very best tarot reading love.
    Scorpio Your all-natural intensity is modified by a much more relaxed an cooperative energy.

  5. Pixel Gun 3D game is such a soort like Minecraft but better
    than it. Pixel Gun 3D has 3D graphics in it and a successful

  6. Excellent post! We will be linking to this particularly great article on our site.

    Keep up the great writing.

  7. Designed by Halfbrick Studios, Jetpack Joyride is a racing recreation that can be very addictive!

  8. Now consider an additional drawing sheet (not extremely thick) and reduce it to the dimension of entrance of the card.

    Also, there are many artists and designers on EBay promoting retro greeting playing cards.

  9. A mobile game developers, at least iOS 3. In fact, in this
    way they can develop his skills, whereas scrabble
    games increase the knowledge of the same time. Today, there is a conventional casino game.
    Gone are the extended addition to this study by National
    Cyber -Security Alliance and Google Play.

  10. A registered trademark is one that has actually been entered in the Register of Trademarks.

  11. Along with government registration, each of the fifty US states has its own heating and cooling unit
    of trademark registration.

  12. On the various other hand, for a class project greater than 10 years ago I talked to a variety of Doctors
    concerning their sensations to the insurance
    policy market.

  13. Now on the other side when we consider the downsides then they are quite much less however all such
    that exist suffice for damaging the IT solutions.

  14. Hence, you could make sure almost all video clip conversion services providers are good as well as might be
    the very best as all of them intend to defeat the others as well as gain the
    count on and also patronage of customers.

  15. However we ought to additionally realize numerous other nations such as the Eastern countries were using these services considering that last decade.

  16. These services range from house cleansing jobs like carpet
    upholstery, mattress as well as cleaning cleansing to duct as well as heater cleaning,
    smokeshaft and also clothes dryer duct cleansing, windows and also awning cleansing, A/C
    cleansing and different workplace cleaning company also.

  17. Web service customers operate as clients to
    the windows registry servers as well as to the internet services.

  18. Dr. Thaler finished magna orgasm laude from Amherst College, got
    his M.D. from Fight it out College as well as completed his residency
    in Interior Medication at Harvard’s New England Deaconess Healthcare
    facility and Holy place College Medical facility.

  19. Some oral schools and facilities could have a rather lengthy waiting period for their

  20. Broadband satellite net is an exceptional
    selection for businesses with workplaces spread over
    different geographic areas.

  21. The major telecommunications supplier Orange (formerly France Télécom) remains to control
    the marketplace for the supply of internet services in France, especially in rural

  22. Government Local business Grants are a great means to money a
    business launch. Look at it like this.

  23. In addition to the typical financial institutions
    and also financing orthodontists, you could likewise consider getting government company loan programs.

  24. In the meanwhile, I’m visiting start trying out goat cheese and also perhaps yogurt.

  25. At the exact same time, other individuals
    that additionally fail to take one’s business seriously could be the reason that most home based business

  26. hello!,I love your writing so a lot! percentage we
    keep in touch extra about your article on AOL? I require an expert
    on this space to resolve my problem. Maybe that is you!
    Having a look forward to look you.

  27. Quality articles is thhe important to attract tthe people
    too go to see the website, that’s what this web site is providing.

  28. Hi there Dear, are you really visiting this site on a regular basis, if so then
    you will definitely take good knowledge.

  29. That is really attention-grabbing, You’re an excessively professional blogger.
    I have joined your rss feed and look ahead to seeking extra of your fantastic post.
    Also, I’ve shared your site in my social networks

Some HTML is OK

or, reply to this post via trackback.